|
A Research Paper on Wilderness Therapy
|
WILDERNESS THERAPY AS AN INTERVENTION AND TREATMENT FOR ADOLESCENTS WITH BEHAVIORAL PROBLEMS
By Keith C. Russell and John C. Hendee Wilderness Research Center
University of Idaho Moscow, Idaho 83843-1144 Telephone: (208) 885-2267 Fax: (208)
885-2268 E-Mail: wrc@uidaho.edu
In: Watson, Alan E., Aplet, Greg, and Hendee, John C.
(1999) Personal, Societal, and Ecological Values of Wilderness: 6th World Wilderness
Congress Proceedings on Research Management and Allocation. Volume II, Proc. RMRS-P-000. Ogden, UT:
USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station.
Keith C. Russell is research associate and John C.
Hendee is Professor and Director, University of Idaho-Wilderness Research Center, Moscow,
ID 83843
Abstract
Wilderness therapy is an emerging intervention and treatment to help adolescents overcome
emotional, adjustment, addiction, and psychological problems. Contained System wilderness
therapy programs are usually up to three-weeks long, operating in a wilderness expedition model in
which clients and leaders stay together for the duration of the trip. Continuous Flow System
programs are longer, up to 8 weeks in length, and have clients continually admitted to on-going
groups with leaders rotating in and out of the field.
In both contained and continuous flow wilderness therapy systems, the therapeutic process includes
the careful selection of appropriate clients, based on a clinical assessment, and the creation of
an individual treatment plan for each participant. Individual and group therapy techniques are
applied in a wilderness setting and facilitated by qualified professionals, with formal evaluative
procedures used to assess the clients' progress. Wilderness therapy utilizes expedition-based
outdoor pursuits such as backpacking, educational curricula including primitive skills such as fire
making, and provides extended periods of introspective alone time for clients. Wilderness self care
and group safety are facilitated by natural consequences, thereby teaching personal and social
responsibility, and creating a neutral and safe environment to apply the real and metaphoric
lessons learned to life situations with which clients are struggling.
Adolescent boys with behavioral problems are the most prevalent clients, a majority of whom have
diagnoses which are drug and alcohol related. Wilderness therapy treatment includes: 1) a cleansing
phase, which occurs early in the program; 2) a personal and social responsibility phase, a
particular focus once the cleansing phase is well underway or complete; and 3) transition and
aftercare phase.
Recent surveys have identified 38 wilderness therapy programs operating in the United States, and
in this paper data from five such programs are projected to illustrate the vitality, relative size,
and potential resource use of wilderness therapy. If we extrapolate the data as if they represented
the 38 known programs, a suggested total of 11,600 clients were served in 1997 and 12,005 in 1998,
generating 340,290 wilderness field days (wfd) in 1997 and 392,000 wfd in 1998 respectively, and
generating annual gross revenues of $128 million dollars in 1997 and $143 million dollars in 1998.
Better communication between wilderness managers and wilderness therapy leaders would help close an
existing gap in understanding between what are necessary and desirable practices for the benefit of
wilderness-this a concern for wilderness therapy programs since they need wilderness to operate, as
well as wilderness mangers, who are mandated to protect the ecological integrity of wilderness.
This strengthened relationship can help deal with misperceptions about wilderness therapy, minimize
impacts on wilderness, and maximize benefits from wilderness therapy as a positive intervention in
the lives of troubled adolescents.
Wilderness Therapy as an Intervention and Treatment for Adolescents with Behavioral Problems
Wilderness therapy is an emerging intervention and treatment in mental health practice to help
adolescents overcome emotional, adjustment, addiction, and psychological problems. The wilderness
therapy process involves immersion in an unfamiliar environment, group living with peers,
individual and group therapy sessions, educational curricula, including a mastery of primitive
skills such as fire-making and backcountry travel, all designed to address problem behaviors and
foster personal and social responsibility and emotional growth of clients.
Mental health providers, insurance companies, and juvenile authorities are beginning to accept
wilderness therapy as a viable alternative to traditional mental health services because of it's
relative effectiveness and lower cost compared to traditional residential and outpatient treatment.
Following is an overview of wilderness therapy, drawing upon our recent research on the use of
wilderness for personal growth and current data from five wilderness therapy programs.
Wilderness Therapy Defined
Wilderness therapy is often confused with the broader field of wilderness experience programs
(WEPs) aimed at the personal growth of participants, such as Outward Bound and other adventure
challenge programs, or reflective experience programs, such as wilderness vision questing.
Wilderness therapy programs are only a small part of the larger wilderness experience program (WEP)
industry, consisting of about 40 programs compared to 500 in the larger category (Friese, Hendee,
& Kinziger, 1998). More precisely, the definition of wilderness therapy includes the careful
selection of appropriate clients, based on a clinical assessment, and the creation of an individual
treatment plan for each participant (Davis-Berman and Berman, 1994, p. 13). Individual and group
therapy techniques are applied in a wilderness setting and facilitated by qualified professionals,
with formal evaluative procedures used to assess the clients' progress. Wilderness therapy utilizes
expedition-based outdoor pursuits such as backpacking, educational curricula including primitive
skills such as fire making, and provides extended periods of introspective alone time for clients.
Wilderness self care and group safety are facilitated by natural consequences that help teach teach
personal and social responsibility, and create a neutral and safe environment to apply the real and
metaphoric lessons learned to the life situations with which clients are struggling.
The Emergence of Wilderness Therapy
Adolescents in the United States are very much at risk, brought on in recent years by profound
cultural changes, including unstructured home environments from an increase in two-income
households and one-parent families, and a media culture that bombards adolescents with images of
sex, violence and excitement. These and other cultural stimuli have contributed to the epidemic of
emotional disorders in US adolescents. Four million of the 26 million adolescents between the ages
of 12 and 19 have emotional problems severe enough to require treatment, with a Center for Disease
Control study indicating that one out of 12 high school students attempted suicide in the year
preceding the study (In Davis-Berman & Berman, 1994). These disturbing statistics are
consistent with the estimate that between 70% to 80% of the children with clinical mental disorders
may not be getting the mental services they need (Tuma, 1989).
Not enough mental health services are available that are suited for adolescents' unique needs.
There is a lack of middle ground between outpatient services, which may be inadequate and to which
adolescents are often unlikely to commit, and inpatient programs which may be overly restrictive
(Tuma, 1989). Wilderness therapy is helping bridge the gap between these extremes, it's appeal
strengthened by a growing reputation for economy and therapeutic effectiveness when compared with
other mental health services.
Current Status of the Wilderness Therapy Industry
Data about the wilderness therapy industry are scarce, but recent surveys provide a basis for
estimating the number of wilderness therapy programs currently operating. Friese (1996) identified
500 wilderness experience programs (WEPs), defined as organizations that conduct outdoor programs
in wilderness or comparable lands for purposes of personal growth, therapy, rehabilitation,
education or leadership and organizational development. Thirty programs fitting the definition of
wilderness therapy were identified in this survey. Subsequently, Carpenter (1998) identified six
additional wilderness therapy programs beyond these, and Crisp (1996) identified two more
expedition-based US wilderness therapy programs not identified by Friese and Carpenter. Thus, a
minimum of 38 wilderness therapy programs have been identified in the US, with perhaps a few
additional programs missed in these three surveys.
Cooley (1998) estimates that approximately 10,000 adolescents are being served by wilderness
treatment on an annual basis, generating 330,000 user days and $60 million in annual revenue. In
the following we present data from five wilderness therapy programs that illustrate the vitality,
relative size, and potential resource use of wilderness therapy (see Tables 1 and 2). While these
programs are not a random sample, it is interesting to generalize them as if they represented the
38 wilderness therapy programs identified by Friese (1996), Crisp (1997), and Carpenter (1998).
Since our data represent a spectrum of programs in size, ranging from 200 to 500 clients served
annually, they resemble an adequate profile, and allow a data-based assessment of the industry. In
fact, these data are a conservative estimate due to a high probability that there are additional
programs not identified by the previously mentioned surveys, and because these data only include
those programs that are expedition-based-there are additional programs utilizing wilderness therapy
principles but operating from a base-camp model.
Our data indicate that all five programs grew in clients served from 1997 to1998, with three of the
five increasing the number of trips they offered (see Table 1). Wilderness field days (wfd) were
calculated by multiplying clients served by the length of the wilderness trip phase of the program,
generating approximately 44,775 wfd in 1997, and 51, 590 wfd in 1998 for the five programs. If we
extrapolate the data as if they represented the 38 known programs, a suggested total of 11,600
clients were served in 1997 and 12,005 in 1998, generating 340,290 wfd in 1997 and 392,000 wfd in
1998 respectively, and generating annual gross revenues of $128 million dollars in 1997 and $143
million dollars in 1998. Until data from more detailed studies of the industry are available, we
believe these estimates offer the clearest picture of the current status of the wilderness therapy
industry (note how close estimates of clients and user days are to those made by Cooley (1998), an
experienced leader in the industry).
Table 1. Statistics on five wilderness therapy programs*.
Program Name
|
Program Length
|
Number of Trips
|
Clients Served
|
Wilderness Field Days
|
|
|
|
1997
|
1998
|
1997
|
1998
|
1997
|
1998
|
|
Anasazi
|
56 days
|
27
|
27
|
187
|
200
|
10,472
|
11,200
|
|
Ascent
|
42 days
|
42
|
43
|
329
|
375
|
3,472
|
5,250
|
Aspen Achieve Academy
|
53 days
|
75
|
75
|
300
|
350
|
15,900
|
18,550
|
Catherine Freer
|
21 days
|
43
|
45
|
256
|
300
|
5,376
|
6,300
|
|
SUWS
|
21 days
|
72
|
75
|
455
|
490
|
9,555
|
10,290
|
|
Totals
|
(Average) 38 days
|
259
|
265
|
1,527
|
1,715
|
44,775
|
51,590
|
*From knowledgeable estimates by
executives in each program in telephone
interviews by Keith Russell, October 1998.
Given reasonable support from federal land management, medical insurance, social service agencies,
and juvenile authorities, wilderness therapy should continue to grow as a positive intervention and
treatment for adolescents with problem behaviors, and who may also be struggling with drug and
alcohol addictions. While wilderness therapy is expensive, our data indicate that clients at some
programs are receiving co-pay medical insurance assistance ranging from 0-60% depending on the
program (see Table 2).
Table 2. Cost & placement results of five wilderness therapy programs*.
|
Program
|
Total Staff
|
Wilderness Treatment Costs
|
Percent Clients with Insurance Co-Pay
|
Percent Aftercare Placement
|
|
Anasazi
|
60
|
$15,000 ($270/day)
|
60% All or Partial 40% Private
|
90% Return Home 10% Aftercare Placement
|
|
Ascent
|
80
|
$18,000 ($440/day)
|
30% All or Partial 70% Private
|
20% Return Home 80% Aftercare Placement
|
|
Aspen Achieve. Academy
|
65
|
$15,700 ($300/day)
|
40% All or Partial 60% Private
|
50% Return Home 50% Aftercare Placement
|
|
Catherine Freer
|
40
|
$5,850 ($280/day)
|
65% All or Partial 35% Private
|
65% Return Home 35% Aftercare Placement
|
|
SUWS
|
58
|
$6,750 ($352/day)
|
0% All or Partial 100% Private
|
40% Return Home 60% Aftercare Placement
|
*From knowledgeable estimates by
executives in each program in telephone interviews
by Keith Russell, October 1998.
Wilderness Therapy Clients
A typical participant in a wilderness therapy program is described in the literature as a juvenile
delinquent, a socio-pathic character or an anti-social personality (McCord, 1995). Another profile
from the literature describes wilderness therapy clients as "males between 13 and 15 years of age
with a history of abuse and neglect, a history of theft, truancy, drug use, arson, vandalism,
assault, promiscuity; intensely physical behavior characterized by impulsivity, recklessness,
destructiveness, and aggression; relatively weak verbal skills; and interpersonal relationships
based not on mutual trust but on manipulation and exploitation (Marx, 1988).
McCord (1995) surveyed clients over a two-year period using the MMPI personality scale and
identified three types of participants with the following characteristics: (1) The
Nonconformist: Likely to be chronically angry and resentful. Tends to be passive aggressive but
may act out on occasion. Immature and narcissistic, defies convention through dress and behavior.
(2) The Party Animal: Often in trouble with parents and other authorities because of
stereotypical delinquent behaviors: drug and alcohol abuse, sneaking out at night, early sexual
experimentation. Energetic and highly extroverted. (3) Emotionally Disturbed: The group
feeling the most subjective distress, including feelings of depression and despair, confusion, and
dismay. Their behavior tends to be erratic, unpredictable, and highly impulsive. Poor achievement
and substance abuse is common (p. 55).
According to interviews with key staff in programs we are studying, typical clientele are
adolescents, up to 70% male with drug and alcohol related diagnoses, and range from 14 to 18 years
of age. Based on social history profiles and initial assessment by clinical staff, diagnoses are
made using the DSM-IV manual of mental disorders to determine medical insurance eligibility and to
help guide development of a treatment plan. Typical diagnoses include drug and alcohol abuse,
anti-social behavior, conduct disorder, and depression. Contrary to what one might expect given the
substantial cost of treatment, many clients come from middle-class backgrounds, with parents
sometimes re-financing their homes or taking out loans to pay for treatment (Cooley, 1998).
Wilderness Therapy Phases and Primary Goals
Wilderness therapy is being increasingly used as a last resort intervention for adolescents who are
in serious trouble due to alcohol and drug use, sexual promiscuity, trouble with the law, and
intense parental conflict. Phone calls of inquiry taken by admissions personnel commonly deal with
parents who are in crisis, and in many cases, literally fear for the adolescent's life. As a
director of one program put it, "in many cases, we are literally reaching under water and grabbing
the hand of a drowning victim" (Paul Smith, personal communication, August 1998) Thus, a high
proportion of wilderness therapy admissions occur with a great sense of urgency to intervene before
the adolescent self destructs or moves into more serious problem behaviors as an adult.
Three phases of wilderness therapy are also primary goals for treatment and are defined as follows:
1) a cleansing phase, which occurs early in the program; 2) a personal and social responsibility
phase, a particular emphasis once the cleansing phase is well underway or complete; and 3)
transition and aftercare phase. Each of these program goals are reviewed in the following.
1. Cleansing Phase. The initial goal of wilderness treatment is to rid clients of chemical
dependencies by removing them from the destructive environments that perpetuated their addictions.
The cleansing is accomplished with a minimal but healthy diet, intense physical exercise, and the
teaching of basic survival and self care skills. The clients are also removed from the trappings of
their former environment including numerous distractions of adolescent culture. The cleansing
process is in itself therapeutic and prepares the client for more in-depth work later in the program.
2. Personal and Social Responsibility Phase. After the initial cleansing phase, natural
consequences and peer interaction are strong therapeutic influences helping clients to learn and
accept personal and social responsibility. Self care and personal responsibility are facilitated by
natural consequences in wilderness, not by authority figures, whom troubled adolescents are prone
to resist. If they choose not to set up a tarp and it rains, the client gets wet, and there is no
one to blame but themselves. If they do not want to make a fire or do not learn to start fires with
a bow drill or flint, they will eat raw oats instead of cooked. A goal is to help clients
generalize metaphors of self care and natural consequences to real life, often a difficult task for
adolescents. For example, adolescents may look at counselors and laugh when told "Stay in school
and it will help you get a job." These long term cause and effect relationships are made more
cogent when therapists and wilderness guides point out the personal and interpersonal dynamics of
the clients' wilderness therapy experience to their lives.
There is strong evidence that social skill deficiencies are related to disruptive and anti-social
behavior, which limits abilities to form close personal relationships (Mathur & Rutherford,
1994). Thus, delinquent behavior may be a manifestation of social skill deficits which can be
changed by teaching appropriate social behaviors. Wilderness therapy takes place in very intense
social units (usually six clients and three leaders) with wilderness living conditions making
cooperation and communication essential for safety and comfort. Proper ways to manage anger, share
emotions, and process interpersonal issues within the group are modeled and practiced in a neutral
and safe environment. Thus, wilderness therapy provides hands on teaching in personal and social
responsibility, with modeling and practice of appropriate social skills and cooperative behaviors,
all reinforced by logical and natural consequences from the wilderness conditions.
3. Transition and Aftercare Phase. Upon completion of the wilderness therapy program ,
clients must implement their newly learned self care and personal and social responsibility to
either home or a structured aftercare placement. Preparation for this challenge is facilitated by
therapists through intense one-on-one and group sessions with peers. If a goal for a client was to
"communicate better with parents," the therapist helps them develop strategies to accomplish this
goal. If abstaining from drugs and alcohol is a goal, then the therapist will work with the client
to develop a behavior contract and strategy with clear expectations including weekly visits to
Alcoholic Anonymous (AA) meetings, and reinforced by regular outpatient counseling sessions. In the
five programs we studied (see Table 2), up to 80% of the clients may go to post wilderness therapy
placement in a structured aftercare setting, such as a residential mental health facility, drug and
alcohol treatment center or an emotional growth boarding school. Follow-up outpatient counseling is
recommended for virtually all clients. Thus, while providing for effective intervention, diagnosis
and initial treatment, wilderness therapy is not a stand alone cure.
Wilderness Therapy Theoretical Foundations and Applications
Wilderness treatment is generally guided by a "family systems" perspective (Satir, 1967), which
incorporates into treatment the family or social system from which the client came. This is a
departure from the widely known "hoods-in-the-woods" programs that view the problem behavior of
adolescents as the main focus of therapy. Many wilderness therapy programs will not accept a client
unless parents state they are willing to be actively involved in the therapeutic process. This
means that the parents themselves will be involved in outside therapy while the client is
participating in the wilderness program, trying to understand how their interactions and
relationship with their child relate to problem behaviors.
Thus, most wilderness therapy programs recognize that parents contribute to adolescents
dysfunctional behavior, and that without parent counseling, the positive outcomes of treatment
could quickly fade if the client returns to a dysfunctional home environment. Wilderness therapy
trips are designed to simulate family living, as all clients learn and practice self care and
personal responsibility, effective peer interaction, and are led by wilderness guides and
therapists modeling effective adult communication and parenting skills.
Application of the wilderness therapy process is decisively shaped by the length of the program,
resulting in two distinct logistical arrangements that we describe as: 1) contained wilderness
therapy systems; and 2) continuous flow wilderness therapy systems, referring to whether or not
clients are rotated in and out of programs in process. Each of these systems will be reviewed and
followed by a description of a typical wilderness therapy program process.
Applications in Contained and Continuous Flow Wilderness Therapy Systems
Contained wilderness therapy programs are usually up to three-weeks long and operate in a
wilderness expedition model in which clients and leaders stay together for the duration of the
trip. The group is self sufficient in their wilderness living and hiking , and are staffed with a
Masters level, licensed therapist, a wilderness guide and an assistant wilderness guide. Ratios of
one staff to two clients is becoming an accepted industry standard.
Depending on the program and the process, a medical diagnosis is made by a supervising therapist
for each client and labeled according to the DSM-IV criteria. Staff are briefed as to the social
history, behavioral, and clinical issues of each client, where ideas and concerns are shared with
staff members about desirable intervention strategies, and an initial treatment plan is developed
with goals and outcomes for each client. Then the group, led by the wilderness guide, licensed
therapist, and assistant guide, leave on a wilderness trip for up to three weeks in length.
Continuous Flow Wilderness Therapy Systems
Continuous flow programs are longer, up to 8 weeks in length, and have leaders rotating in and out
of the field--eight days on and six days off is a typical rotation for staff. Clients are
continually entering and leaving the program as new "intakes" are brought to existing treatment
groups to replace "graduates," who are leaving treatment after having met their goals. When new
clients arrive they go through an intake process of physicals, discussions with the clinical staff,
are outfitted with equipment and driven to the trailhead to meet with an on-going treatment group.
The typical in-take will admit up to eight students at a time and spread the clients out over two
or three on-going groups in the field.
The groups will welcome new members and introduce themselves using an established format, and
discuss any issues of importance about how the group operates. Those clients who are further along
in their treatment assume roles of responsibility and are looked up to by the new clients. The peer
role modeling and mentoring process begins almost immediately, as staff take a back seat to the
more experienced clients who facilitate many of the lessons that need to be taught for the new
clients to survive in this harsh and new environment.
Wilderness guides, not licensed therapists, are with the clients in the field on a daily basis.
Therapists are assigned to a group of clients and visit them weekly, going to the field during
group lay-over days and conducting one-to-two hour sessions with each client discussing issues,
processing their homework for the week, or relaying information from parents. After the session is
over the therapist will give the client an assignment to complete for the week, such as bringing up
a certain issue in group and observing the reactions of the other group members. A structured group
therapy session is then facilitated, often guided by a metaphoric lesson or a psycho-educational
topic for the week.
Typical Wilderness Therapy Process
After the initial shock of the dramatic change in environment, clients begin to display behavior
patterns consistent with their social history profiles. Staff routinely meet and discuss treatment
strategies, such as increased responsibility for a client who lacks self esteem, or suggesting that
a client who is having trouble expressing themselves bring up personal issues in group sessions.
Individual one-on-one counseling sessions are coupled with intermittent group counseling throughout
the trip. The individual counseling sessions can take place on the trail, in a client's shelter
area, or while whittling sticks when making a bow-drill fire set. This neutral environment and
unorthodox approach eliminates many of the barriers associated with traditional therapeutic
counseling, such as intimidation by the therapist or the stigma of going to a "hospital" because
they are "sick." In a wilderness setting the therapist can be seen as a person and not as a
threatening authority figure. Therapists work on establishing rapport with the client, earning
their trust and doing initial assessment of the underlying issues. Lessons learned in these
impromptu "sessions" are relayed to other field staff and documented in daily and weekly treatment notes.
Groups sessions are held at least daily and range from being loosely organized, where the clients
direct the flow of discussion, or extremely structured, where a reading will be presented and the
group will focus on it's direct meaning. The goal of the group sessions is to provide clients an
opportunity to share feelings and emotions that have begun to emerge in the course of treatment.
Groups play a valuable role in allowing students a safe and controlled environment to practice some
of the new interpersonal skills they are learning and hear the stories of other clients. The
feeling of group cohesion that develops through these candid interactions is of major therapeutic
value for clients, virtually all of whom feel alienated from well adjusted peers due to their
dysfunctional behavior and problems.
As the trip continues, calls will be made via cell phone or radio back to base camp to communicate
with therapeutic staff working directly with the client's parents. Needless to say, parents are
experiencing considerable anxiety, guilt and regret that their children are being put through this
experience and often blame themselves for their children's problems. Parents may also be in
counseling and beginning to realize that they may be part of the problem and also need to change.
The field staff encourage the adolescents to write their parents and express their feelings about
the past and describe changes they want to make at home to help foster a better family environment.
Parents may need help from therapists in understanding the sometimes negative and blaming tone of
these letters. Thus, the parents become part of and invested in the therapeutic process and are
kept aware of the progress their child is making.
As the wilderness therapy program unfolds, decisions are made as to the necessary follow-up care
for the client and an aftercare treatment strategy is developed. In some cases, three-week programs
are used primarily for diagnosis and assessment, cleansing and stabilizing the client to prepare
them for placement into an aftercare facility such as a boarding school, drug and alcohol treatment
center or residential psychiatric facility (see Table 2). Depending on the seriousness of the
client's issues, eight-week programs may also serve this purpose, although more clients return to
families than go on to aftercare in the eight-week programs for which we have data (see Table 2).
A recommendation for aftercare treatment can be shocking and unexpected for the client, for in many
cases they believed that all they had to do was complete the program and they would be allowed to
go home and see their friends. The therapists and wilderness guides work with the client in intense
one-on-one sessions to help them see and accept that the recommended aftercare is the best move for
them, given the circumstances of their past behavior. Experience confirms that in most cases,
unless assessments and recommendation growing out of wilderness therapy are followed, clients may
quickly revert to prior behavioral patterns of resistance.
As the wilderness program draws to a conclusion, the focus is on generalizing the lessons learned
and preparing clients for their next step in the recommended continuum of care. Clients are busy
working on journal assignments, preparing word-for-word what they want to say to their parents, and
completing necessary tasks such as educational curriculum or a primitive skill checklist, to assure
that they will graduate on time. After two to several weeks in the field, living and traveling in
the wilderness is as second nature to clients as grabbing the remote control and turning on the
television. The focus is now on their personal issues and how they plan to tell their parents,
therapists, and/or the aftercare facility that they have indeed learned something, want to change
for the better, and have an action plan to do so while staying clean and sober from drugs and
alcohol. If the program has worked the meeting with parents is emotional and frightening and the
first step in the right direction to making better choices and improving relationships with family.
Implications for Wilderness Management
Though the value of wilderness to mental health has been extolled for decades, mental health
institutions and medical insurance companies are just now beginning to embrace wilderness therapy
as an effective intervention and treatment for adolescents with problem behaviors. Parents by the
thousands, desperate to save their adolescents from self-destructive behavior and drugs and
alcohol, continue to turn to wilderness therapy. Our data suggests that these trends and pressures
are leading to significant wilderness use, 392,000 user days or more per year by 38 known
wilderness therapy programs, in an enterprise collectively generating at least $143 million dollars
annually. We see at least three primary wilderness management implications from these trends.
Wilderness Therapy is a Growing Wilderness Use
Our data indicate a substantial and growing amount of wilderness use from at least 38 wilderness
therapy programs, which is but a small part of the much larger wilderness experience program (WEP)
industry that includes 500 WEPs. Wilderness managers recognize these increases; Gager and others
(1998) found in a national survey that virtually all wilderness managers perceived increases of WEP
use in areas they administered.
A key issue is whether or not WEP use, including wilderness therapy, depends on designated
wilderness to meet their goals. Gager and others (1998) found that a majority of wilderness
managers believe that wilderness therapy program activities are not wilderness dependent, but two
recent surveys of WEPs revealed that more than half the respondents say they operate in designated
wilderness (Friese, 1996) and do regard their programs as depending on wilderness (Dawson and
others 1999). Managers fears of WEPs identified by Gager (1998) include establishing new trails,
overuse in areas already saturated, site impacts, large group size, lack of wilderness stewardship
skills and knowledge, and conflicts with other users (p. 35).
Demand for wilderness use may soon overwhelm the capacities established by managers and raises
difficult questions. Can we, or should we lower standards for naturalness and solitude? Can enough
new areas be brought into the wilderness system to expand capacity? Is the use of wilderness for
personal growth and healing of young people more important from a social and economic standpoint
than commercial recreation use, or casual use by the public?
Wilderness Therapy Has Unique Impacts on Wilderness
The use of primitive skills as a wilderness therapy tool may expand normal impacts of wilderness
use, and in some places adjustments may be needed. For example, if ten clients make two fires a day
for 36 days it would equal 720 fires throughout the course of one program! Already aware of these
potential impacts, many programs have begun self regulating the use of fire, striving to maintain
it's therapeutic value while conserving the resource. For example, the Anasazi program which often
operates on the Tonto National Forest in Arizona, now uses primitive methods to ignite a coal,
which is then used to light propane stoves for cooking. This reduces fire scars, depletion of fuel
wood, and other impacts. Catherine Freer Wilderness Therapy, which often operates in the Kalmiopsis
Wilderness Area in Oregon, also uses primitive fire making in structured lessons in pre-established
areas, but cooks over gas stoves to lessen their impacts.
Strengthen Communication and Cooperation
Enhanced communication and cooperation is needed between agency managers and wilderness therapy
leaders to coordinate use and address impacts with new strategies. For example, work projects might
be completed by wilderness therapy programs with therapeutic effects for participants, crowded
areas can be avoided during peak times, and strict leave-no-trace principles can be practiced.
Better communication would also help close the gap in understanding between what are necessary and
desirable practices for the benefit of wilderness. This a concern for wilderness therapy programs
since they need wilderness to operate, as well as for wilderness mangers who are mandated to
protect the ecological integrity of wilderness. A strengthened relationship would help deal with
misperceptions about wilderness therapy, minimize impacts on wilderness and maximize benefits from
wilderness therapy as a positive intervention in the lives of troubled adolescents.
LITERATURE CITED
Carpenter, J. (1998). Program evaluation practices in wilderness
therapy for youth-at-risk. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Idaho, Moscow.
Cooley, R. (1998). Wilderness therapy can help troubled teens.
International Journal of Wilderness, 4(3).
Crisp, S. (1996). International models of best practice in wilderness
and adventure therapy: Implications for Australia. (Final Report ). Melbourne, Australia: Winston
Churchill Fellowship.
Davis-Berman, J., & Berman, D. S. (1994). Wilderness Therapy:
Foundations, theories and research. Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt Publishing.
Dawson, C. P., Friese, G. T., Tangen-Foster, J., & Carpenter, J.
(1998). Wilderness experience programs in the United States: Their dependence on wilderness. In:
Watson, Alan E., Aplet, Greg, and Hendee, John C. (1999) Personal, Societal, and Ecological Values
of Wilderness: 6th World Wilderness Congress Proceedings on Research Management and Allocation.
Volume I, Proc. RMRS-P-000. Ogden, UT.
Friese, G., Hendee, J. C., & Kinziger, M. (1998). The wilderness
experience program industry in the United States: Characteristics and dynamics. Journal of
Experiential Education, 21(1), 40-45.
Friese, G. T. (1996). Inventory and classification of wilderness
experience programs. Unpublished Masters Thesis, University of Idaho, Moscow, ID.
Gager, D., Hendee, J., Kinziger, M., & Krumpe, E. (1998). What
managers are saying and doing about wilderness experience programs. Journal of Forestry, 96(8), 33-37.
Marx, J. D. (1988). An outdoor program for adolescents. Social Work,
33, 517-520.
Mathur, S. R., & Rutherford, R. B. (1994). Teaching conversational
social skills to delinquent youth. Behavioral Disorders, 19, 294-305.
McCord, D. M. (1995). Toward a typology of wilderness-based residential
treatment program participants. Residential Treatment for Children and Youth, 12(4), 51-60.
Satir, V. (1967). Conjoint family therapy. Pal Alto, CA: Science and
Behavior Books, Inc.
Tuma, J. (1989). Mental health services for children: The state of the
art. American Psychologist, 44, 188-199.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Keith C. Russell, Ph.D. Candidate University of Idaho, Wilderness
Research Center CFWR, Room 18a Moscow, ID 83844-1144 USA Tel: 208.885.2269; Fax:
208.885.2268; Email: keith934@uidaho.edu
Keith C. Russell is a Ph.D. candidate and Research Associate with the
University of Idaho Wilderness Research Center in Moscow, Idaho USA studying the use of wilderness
for personal growth and therapy. He co-teaches courses in the use of wilderness for personal
growth, wilderness therapy, and teaches whitewater kayaking. He has been a wilderness educator and
guide for ten years in the US, Mexico, Costa Rica, and New Zealand, with an emphasis on designing,
implementing, and evaluating wilderness experience programs for youth-at-risk.
Dr. John C. Hendee, Professor and Director University of Idaho,
Wilderness Research Center CFWR, Room 18a Moscow, ID 83844-1144 USA Tel: 208.885.2267;
Fax: 208.885.2268; Email: hendeejo@uidaho.edu
Dr. John C. Hendee is Professor and Director of the University of Idaho
Wilderness Research Center in Moscow, Idaho USA, where he teaches and leads research on the use of
wilderness for personal growth and wilderness therapy. He is senior co-author of the textbook
Wilderness Management (1st and 2nd editions), is a founder and Editor in Chief of the International
Journal of Wilderness and a Director and Vice President for science and education of the WILD
Foundation, sponsors of the World Wilderness Congress. He also assists his wife, Marilyn Riley, in
leading programs with her business Wilderness Transitions Inc.
|